Tugas Akhir
Comparative analysis of structural volume and cost estimation for permanent canal block construction using bim software autodesk revit and tekla structures case study: khg burnai river – sibumbung river (kse-sumsel-2018-492) / Muhamad Aji Sumowiguno
Abstrak
The adoption of Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology in construction projects has proven effective in enhancing efficiency and accuracy including in peatland restoration projects such as permanent canal block structures. This study aims to compare volume and cost estimations produced by two BIM software platforms Autodesk Revit 2023 and Tekla Structures 2024. A quantitative descriptive method was employed focusing on the canal block structure located in KHG Sungai Burnai ndash Sungai Sibumbung (KSE-SUMSEL-2018-492). Structural elements including sloof beams walls and floor slabs were modeled using both software followed by volume and cost calculations based on local unit price data. The results show minimal discrepancies concrete volume differences ranged from 0 ndash 2.3% while reinforcement differences ranged from 0.13 ndash 0.68%. Cost estimation deviations remained below 2.5% within the acceptable limit of plusmn 5% set by the AACE Class 3 Estimate. These variations stem from differences in modeling approaches detailing precision and built-in calculation systems within each platform. Tekla Structures excels in structural accuracy and detailing making it suitable for fabrication and construction stages. Autodesk Revit on the other hand is more efficient for early design stages and rapid estimations. This study recommends using Revit during initial planning and Tekla during technical execution along with providing BIM training for field implementers. Future research is encouraged to explore larger-scale water infrastructure projects for broader applicability.