Tugas Akhir
Comparative analysis of volume and cost estimates for structural work using building information modelling (bim) methods autodesk revit and tekla structures / Nadhif Eqwa Taqiy
Abstrak
In the era of globalization the rapid development of information technology particularly in the construction project sector has greatly enhanced project efficiency and effectiveness. One significant indicator of technological progress in the construction industry is the implementation of the Building Information Modeling (BIM) method. Building Information Modeling (BIM) also referred to as Integrated Project Delivery (IPD) is a modeling approach applied in the planning execution and delivery of construction design that emphasizes collaboration integration and effective team management within a project control framework. This study aims to compare the calculation of volumes and cost estimations of the structural works of SMPN 50 Bekasi City using Building Information Modeling through Autodesk Revit and Tekla Structures. The research employed a descriptive quantitative method which analyzes the results of volume calculations and cost estimations of structural works. Both software applications were utilized to model the 3D structure of the building mdash including foundations tie beams beams floor slabs and columns mdash and subsequently generate the volume of each element automatically. The findings indicate differences between the two software results the concrete volume calculated by Autodesk Revit was 5% smaller compared to Tekla Structures with a discrepancy of 11.14 m sup3 . Conversely the reinforcement volume obtained from Autodesk Revit was 6.18% larger than that of Tekla Structures with a difference of 4 318.51 kg. In terms of cost estimation the study reveals that the difference in concrete volume costs between Autodesk Revit and Tekla Structures amounted to IDR 13 479 400 with Autodesk Revit yielding a 5.00% smaller estimate. Meanwhile the discrepancy in reinforcement cost estimation reached IDR 65 209 501 with Tekla Structures producing a 6.18% smaller estimate. The study concludes that both software applications are applicable for building projects where Autodesk Revit demonstrates advantages in handling complex building visualizations while Tekla Structures proves to be more effective in managing detailed structural work