Tugas Akhir
Comparative analysis of quantity take-off estimates and cost estimates using autodesk revit and tekla structures software (case study: rsud eka candrarini construction project in east surabaya) / Mohammad Iqbal Andrean Sumarsono
Abstrak
The Eka Candrarini Regional General Hospital (RSUD) ndash East Surabaya is a fairly large building consisting of 8 floors with a total floor area of approximately 7 807 m sup2 . In this project BIM is still used to visualize the building in three dimensions so calculations for volume and cost estimation are still performed using Microsoft Excel and AutoCAD to open reference drawings. This study aims to compare quantity take-off calculations and cost estimates for the structural work of the Eka Candrarini Regional General Hospital using Autodesk Revit 2023 and Tekla Structures 2024 software. This study uses a quantitative descriptive method with two data sources primary data and secondary data. Primary data was obtained from the detailed engineering design (DED) and bill of quantities (BoQ) of the project while secondary data was obtained from journals and articles related to BIM. The results of the study show that the difference in concrete volume is 0.58% greater in Tekla Structures and the difference in reinforcement volume is 4.04% greater in Tekla Structures while the difference in concrete cost estimation is IDR 132 382 266 and the difference in reinforcement cost estimation is IDR 2 475 220 107. Both software programs can be used for hospital building projects where Revit excels in building visualization and quantity take-off speed while Tekla excels in reinforcement detail.