Tugas Akhir
Analysis of the mechanical strength comparison between grid infill and honeycomb infill structures in 3d printing / Ahmad Muwaffaq Afif
Abstrak
This study aims to analyze and compare the mechanical strength of two types of infill structures namely grid and honeycomb in 3D printed products using PLA filament. The primary objective is to determine the differences in tensile strength performance material usage efficiency and printing time between these two infill patterns at various infill percentages and nozzle temperatures. The study is expected to provide recommendations for selecting the optimal infill structure based on mechanical strength requirements material efficiency and production time in 3D printing applications. In the era of Industry 4.0 3D printing technology is increasingly utilized in The research employed an experimental method with a quantitative approach. The study began with fabricating tensile test specimens using an Ender-3 V3 SE 3D printer with two infill patterns grid and honeycomb at infill percentages of 20% 30% 40% and 50% and nozzle temperatures of 200 deg C and 210 deg C. The specimens were designed according to ASTM D638 Type V standards using Autodesk Inventor software. After printing tensile strength tests were conducted using a Universal Testing Machine (UTM) to measure ultimate tensile strength elongation at break and elastic modulus. The collected data were statistically analyzed to compare the performance of both infill structures and to evaluate material usage efficiency and printing time. The results indicate that the grid infill structure exhibits higher ultimate tensile strength compared to the honeycomb structure across all tested infill percentages and nozzle temperatures. For example at 200 deg C and 50% infill the grid structure achieved a maximum tensile strength of 47.1 MPa while the honeycomb structure reached 42 MPa. However the honeycomb structure demonstrated higher elongation at break and elastic modulus indicating better flexibility and deformation capacity especially at low to medium infill levels. In terms of material efficiency the grid structure produced lighter specimens than the honeycomb at the same infill percentage making it more material-efficient. Additionally the printing time for the grid structure was consistently shorter than that of the honeycomb with the time difference increasing as the infill percentage rose. In conclusion the grid pattern excels in tensile strength and printing time efficiency whereas the honeycomb pattern offers superior flexibility and deformation efficiency. Therefore the choice of infill pattern should be tailored to the specific application requirements.