Tugas Akhir
Comparative analysis of quantity take off of structural work with autodesk revit and tekla structures software / GHOZI KHOIRUN ARRAFI
Abstrak
The development of applications in the construction sector offers various advantages one of which is the implementation of Building Information Modeling (BIM) which enables effective estimation of quantities and costs. This study aims to apply modeling and conduct a comparison of quantity take-off between two BIM software namely Autodesk Revit and Tekla Structures in a three-story luxury residential project. The research data were obtained from the Detail Engineering Design (DED) documents prepared by the planning consultant using a comparative method between the two software. Both Autodesk Revit and Tekla Structures applied the BIM concept in the modeling process. The findings indicate that Autodesk Revit excels in ease of use and document management while Tekla Structures demonstrates superior performance in detailing complex structural elements albeit requiring more advanced technical understanding. Based on the quantity take-off comparison the concrete volume calculated by Tekla Structures was 1.79% higher than Autodesk Revit equivalent to an additional cost of IDR 3 037 365.93. Furthermore the reinforcement volume in Tekla Structures was 5.11% greater compared to Autodesk Revit with a cost difference of IDR 10 953 940.95. Therefore this study is expected to serve as a reference for planners and practitioners in selecting the most appropriate BIM software according to the specific needs of their construction projects. emsp